Messing With People's Lives is Not a Social Experiment
This past week, we learned of a second fraudulent pollster this election cycle. From The Guardian:
A polling firm has admitted to using fabricated data in surveys that were picked up by national media outlets in the US, claiming the project was a “social experiment” designed to expose the lack of scrutiny over the sector.
Wedgewood Polls released a statement on Tuesday on social media, after the polling and election analysis site FiftyPlusOne reached out for comment on an investigation it had conducted into their surveys and data. A polling firm has admitted to using fabricated data in surveys that were picked up by national media outlets in the US, claiming the project was a “social experiment” designed to expose the lack of scrutiny over the sector.
In its statement, Wedgewood Polls admitted to fabricating its numbers, and said the project was designed as a “wake-up call”, intended “to demonstrate the vulnerabilities, lack of oversight, and overall low barrier to entry in the modern political polling industry”.
“Our fabricated numbers were given instant credibility across national media platforms,” the statement said. “The ease with which unverified figures were absorbed into mainstream political narratives highlights a systemic breakdown in media vetting and data aggregation.”
Publications that reproduced Wedgewood Polls’s fraudulent surveys included Newsweek, the Hill, Breitbart, the Daily Beast and the Washington Examiner, and those that included its results in their polling databases included the New York Times, Nate Silver, VoteHub and FiftyPlusOne.
After Wedgewood’s admission, the election results and analysis site Decision Desk HQ said it had removed 17 polls from its race-level polling lists and averages, and the New York Times said in an editor’s note that all of its polls had been removed from its poll tracking project.
Wedgewood Polls first came on the polling scene in June, billing itself as an election survey firm that conducted independent political research. Within weeks, on 10 July, a Washington Monthly columnist noted that its first poll of the Louisiana Republican primary runoff had been “wildly wrong”.
In August, Straight Arrow News then looked into Wedgewood’s background, finding that its website, hosted on Google Sites, listed no employee names, phone number or location. Its website had been registered on 26 June, and its X account created that same month.
On 16 August, an Urban Milwaukee journalist referred to Wedgewood as “a shady outfit” after one of its polls regarding the Wisconsin Democratic primary for governor showed Francesca Hong at 30% “at a time when legitimate polls had her with far less of the vote”.
Adam Carlson, a Democratic pollster at a different firm, told Straight Arrow News that he had communicated with someone at Wedgewood after he raised a question about them on X. Carlson said the person told him the two-person firm includes one progressive and one conservative. They declined to reveal their identities or participate in a video call, claiming that one of the two people at Wedgewood had previously experienced doxing and online harassment.
Wedgewood was apparently a two-person operation led by Republican operative Jack Sims and Democrat Andrew Prater. Sims previously worked as a pollster with SoCal Strategies and had a reputation in Florida GOP circles. Little is known about Prater other than that he allegedly was involved in Ohio Democratic politics, but no verifiable evidence has been found. After this past Tuesday's news, the connection between SoCal Strategies and Wedgewood drew the immediate attention of those trying to unwrap exactly what had happened. Online betting market Kalshi identified a user named AndrewWOhio53 whom they believe is Prater, as the individual in question placed bets prior to the release of three polls from SoCal Strategies. Less than 48 hours after the Wedgewood revelation, SoCal Strategies suddenly went dark, and online sources seemed to imply the reason for that was that Sims had gambled away much of the polling organization's funds to prop up his own personal gambling addiction. At a time when significant amounts of money can be made betting on politics, it seems as if both Sims and Prater were at least partially motivated to profit off of their great "social experiment."
But here's the thing that the Jack Sims, Andrew Praters, and the Rahil Prakashes of previously faked polling outlet Median Strategies need to understand: your little "experiments" have real-world consequences. Those of us who follow politics know polling is broken. We know that there are severe concerns about the modern methodology of polling and how certain technology-savvy generations are oversampled. We know that it takes a certain type of person to willingly take time out of their day to answer a 10-15 minute survey from a complete stranger. We know that those without cellphones or reliable internet are rarely, if ever, included in these polls. None of that is new. By creating these fake polling outlets, you've simply reinforced what we already know. Your great "revelation" that polls aren't vetted to the level they should be is something we were already aware of. Anybody who studies politics knows that there are certain pollsters who always oversample certain voting blocs. Announcing that the process for an unvetted pollster to immediately be taken seriously is not breaking news; it's simply in line with how the entire polling industry has regressed over the past half century.
But in doing what you did, you did more than call attention to this issue. Instead, your fake polls in places like Michigan altered the political landscape of the Democratic Senate primary in that state. Third-place candidate Mallory McMorrow has publicly come forth and has been very vocal in her belief that a June Wedgewood poll dramatically impacted her standing in the race. During that time, the Wedgewood poll showed McMorrow to be in a distant third, with only six percent of respondents being undecided. Yet a Susquehanna poll released around that same time saw a whopping forty-nine percent of respondents being undecided, a number that was much more accurate, as during this time the majority of the electorate was still in the process of learning about the candidates ahead of the August 4th primary. By faking your poll, you gave the impression that McMorrow had much less chance of winning over the undecideds than she actually did. That directly impacted her campaign strategy and impacted how both existing and potential donors saw her campaign. While she might not have won the nomination, your actions undeniably impacted the race for a Senate seat in a critical swing state that Democrats must win to have any chance to take back the Senate from Republican rule.
And that right there shows how little disregard your "experiment" had for human lives. Because this year's midterm elections aren't some game that you can rig for a precious little gotcha! moment. People will live and die as a result of what happens in eight days. There is a world of difference between a Democratic and a Republican Senate. There could potentially be a new conservative Supreme Court Justice who will spend the next 30+ years on the bench if Republicans maintain control of the Senate. There will be several extreme judges appointed to federal positions. There will be a debt ceiling battle next summer, resulting in uncertainty for working-class families and a potential downturn in the market. With split government, we will continue seeing Senate Republicans block everything positive that House Democrats would want to enact. Being in the majority, Senate Republicans will have no motivation to compromise with their counterparts in the lower chamber. By messing with the Michigan primary the way that you did, you've intentionally made it more difficult for the Democrats to fight against the Trump Administration. All so you could point out the obvious fact that polling is deeply flawed in this country.
Personally, I do hope Democrats retake the House and Senate despite your efforts. Not just for the good of the country. But because little shits like you three need to learn a lesson. You need to learn you can't mess with people's lives for some "social experiment." Your actions have consequences. And with Democrats in charge of various committees, there sure as hell needs to be an investigation into fake polling and the people behind it. It may have been a fun little excursion for you three to prove a point and make a few bucks on the side. But you put people's lives at risk in doing so. You made it more difficult for the American people to put a check on Donald Trump's power. This isn't a game for those Americans on the margin. What you did intentionally undermined the democratic process. There can and should be charges against the three of you come next January. Because what you did to prove your little point is something that has had severe consequences that have reverberated throughout the country.
So enjoy these next three months. What happens to you three after that depends on what happens next Tuesday. But know this: we see you for who you are. We see three desperate, needy individuals wanting to make a name for themselves. We see GOP ratfuckers like you, Jack Sims. We see shady desperate individuals trying to keep out of the limelight like you, Andrew Prater. We see recent college grads trying to boost their resume like you, Rahil Prakash. You three are on our radar. And if you're on our radar, you can be sure that you're on the radar of the Democratic Party that you tried so desperately to screw over. You can hide behind the whole "social experiment" line for so long until we begin to unpack what you did and how it can definitely be categorized as fraud, and include all the penalties associated with that charge. Try as you might, you can no longer escape the spotlight you three so desperately sought. It's here, front and center for everyone to see. You three took it upon yourselves to try and fuck over the Democratic Party, and the cost for doing so will become apparent come next January. Try as you may, you're now officially on the radar of some of the most powerful people in the country whose party you tried to intentionally harm this election cycle.
I hope it was worth it.
